READ-13: Reading paced by audio cues

Last updated:

Part of the EchoVision Wish List, under Reading Mode.

The need

When a congregation sings, an owner who can't see the hymnal can join in if someone reads each line to them just before it is sung. At home, with a streamed service, a family member can do this. In church there is no one to read, and reading the whole hymn aloud at once is no help: by the time the singing reaches a verse, it has been forgotten.

EchoVision could read the hymn one line at a time, listen to the singing, and read the next line as the last words of the current line are being sung.

Today's workaround

  • In Reading Mode, tap the touchpad once to pause and again to resume. This gives some control, but reading resumes for a whole section, not one line, so it is hard to keep in step with the singing.
  • Ask the church for the hymn list ahead of time, find the words, and put them in a note or email on the phone, one line at a time. Swipe to the next line with the screen reader just before it is sung. With Route Phone Audio to Glasses turned on, the screen reader speaks through the glasses' open-ear speakers, so you can still hear the congregation and sing along.
  • On an iPhone, if the hymn is in Apple Music, VoiceOver can read the lyrics as the song plays. With Route Phone Audio to Glasses turned on, both play through the glasses, so you can still hear the congregation around you. The lyrics follow the recording, not the congregation, so this is most useful for learning a hymn before the service. See Pairing EchoVision Glasses as Wireless Headphones in the user guide.

What it would look like

  • Reading Mode reads the hymn's text one line at a time, then waits.
  • The glasses listen to the room. As the singing nears the end of the current line, they read the next line quietly, so it is heard just before it is sung.
  • A touchpad tap reads the next line at once, or repeats the last one, if the timing slips.
  • The same pacing could help elsewhere: responsive readings, prayers said together, or reading along with a choir or a performance.

Pros and cons

  • Pro: owners can take part in congregational singing and spoken responses without help.
  • Pro: it builds on Reading Mode's existing text detection and touchpad controls.
  • Con: hard to get right. Following singing in a large, echoing room, with the organ playing, is much harder than recognizing speech, and any delay means the line arrives too late.
  • Con: the glasses would need to listen continuously while reading, which uses more battery and raises privacy questions in a place of worship.
  • Con: playing audio through the glasses' speakers may be heard by people sitting nearby during quiet moments.
  • Con: hymnals often print several verses between the same lines of music, so finding the right line, in the right verse, to read is not simple.

Open questions

  • Is a simpler version useful first: reading one line per tap, with no listening?
  • Could the glasses follow the singing well enough, quickly enough, to read each line in time?
  • How should the hymn get into the glasses: scanned from the hymnal on the spot, or prepared ahead of time in the app?
  • How loud should the line be read, so it is heard over the singing without disturbing others?

History

  • November 5, 2026: Under review. Asked by an owner on the EchoVision Community Forum.